Tutor: So, Leila, Marcus, how is the project on solar water pumps going?
Leila: Mostly well, thanks. We decided to focus on small farms in the Sahel.
Tutor: Why the Sahel, in the end?
Marcus: Partly because I spent a summer in Niger, so I know the area a little. But honestly, the deciding factor was the data. The FAO and several NGOs have published very detailed field reports from that region.
Tutor: Good. And your survey of farmers? How did that go?
Leila: We actually got more replies than we expected, over two hundred, and it didn't take as long as we'd feared. The problem was the question about costs. Many farmers thought we meant the price of buying the pump, not the cost of running it, so the answers can't really be compared.
Tutor: That's a useful lesson for your methodology section. Now, I've looked at your graphs. The colours are fine, and you haven't put too much on each one. What's missing is the units on the axes. A reader can't tell whether you mean litres or cubic metres.
Marcus: Right, we'll fix that.
Tutor: Marcus, in your view, what's the main advantage of solar pumps?
Marcus: People always talk about low maintenance, but the panels still need cleaning, and spare parts can be hard to find. For me the strongest argument is that once the pump is installed, the fuel bill disappears. Running it costs almost nothing.
Leila: And reliability really depends on the season. In the dusty months the output can drop a lot.
Tutor: So, what's your next step?
Leila: We can't afford to travel to a site, unfortunately. We've already read a lot about financing, so we don't need more on that.
Marcus: I think we should contact the engineer at the NGO we mentioned and ask for a video interview.
Leila: Yes, let's do that.
Tutor: Fine. Let's talk about your sources. What did you make of the World Bank report?
Leila: It's thorough, but most of its figures are from 2010, and solar panel prices have fallen enormously since then. It's really too old to help us now.
Tutor: And the manufacturer's brochure?
Marcus: It's easy to read, but of course they want to sell pumps, so they only mention the advantages. We can't rely on it.
Tutor: What about the article in the engineering journal?
Leila: To be honest, it was too technical for us. It's mostly equations about panel efficiency.
Tutor: And the NGO field reports?
Marcus: Those were the most useful. Each one describes a real village, what worked and what didn't, so they give us excellent case studies.
Tutor: And the FAO database?
Leila: That's where we got most of our numbers: rainfall, farm size, water use. It's our main source of statistics. And it's free to access, which helps.