Week 12 of 12 · 12 hours · Diploma

Leading through dilemmas: difficult decisions and a complete CMCoord plan

Objectives of the week
  • Reason through civil-military dilemmas with an explicit, documented method.
  • Exercise CMCoord leadership: convince your management, your peers and armed actors.
  • Present a complete CMCoord plan for a given context, ready to be defended before a humanitarian country team.

Keep the course at home: free PDF handout with exercises, key takeaways and quiz answers.

Download this lesson as PDF Complete manual (PDF)

Your working week : 12 h

The course alone is not enough: this plan spreads the 12 hours of the week. Tick each step once done.

1Why dilemmas are unavoidable

CMCoord often sets two goods against each other: saving lives now thanks to a military asset, or protecting tomorrow's access and security by keeping a distance. No text settles every case. The guidelines provide criteria; the decision remains a judgement.

Examples of dilemmas: accepting a helicopter from a party to the conflict to evacuate wounded people; sharing the location of a hospital that a party might target; using an airstrip controlled by a foreign force; continuing a distribution under the threat of a group demanding a share.

2A decision method

  1. Clarify the need: who, how many, how urgent, what consequences if nothing is done.
  2. List the options, including civilian options and the "do nothing" option.
  3. Assess each option against the criteria: last resort, effects on principles and perception, real security, effects on other organisations, duration and exit.
  4. Consult: OCHA, civil-military forum, management and, where possible, communities.
  5. Decide at the right level, in writing, with conditions and a review date.
  6. Explain the decision to partners and communities.
  7. Learn lessons afterwards.

3CMCoord leadership

An effective CMCoord manager:

  • knows the texts and the context better than their counterparts;
  • builds trust with humanitarians (who sometimes fear any interaction) and with the military (who do not always understand refusals);
  • proposes instead of only refusing: "no escort, but here is what we ask for road safety";
  • holds the collective line when one organisation is tempted to go it alone;
  • documents so that memory survives rotations, both military and humanitarian.

4The complete CMCoord plan

The final assignment of this programme is a CMCoord plan for a real or realistic context, 8 to 10 pages long:

  1. Context analysis and mapping of armed actors.
  2. Position on the spectrum for each actor, justified.
  3. Main operational rules (military assets, escorts, distinction, meetings).
  4. Information sharing and humanitarian notification.
  5. Access: impediments, red lines, negotiation strategy.
  6. Protection: camps, gender, PSEA, children.
  7. Organisation: roles, forums, liaison, handovers.
  8. Scenarios, warning indicators and planned decisions.
  9. Indicators for monitoring coordination.

5After this programme

This Mini MBA is an independent course of the Humanitarian Academy. To go further:

  • take OCHA's free online modules on civil-military coordination;
  • apply for the UN-CMCoord course organised by OCHA and its partners;
  • take part in your country's civil-military forums and in regional exercises;
  • regularly read the country-specific guidelines published on ReliefWeb.

The diploma of this programme certifies that you passed the Academy's exams; it is not a United Nations certification.

Exercise: the evacuation dilemma

After a bombing, 9 seriously wounded people are in a health centre supported by your NGO. The nearest hospital is 6 hours away by road. The national army, a party to the conflict, offers a helicopter within the hour. No civilian air asset is available before 48 hours. The armed group controlling the neighbouring area has already accused your NGO of "working for the army".

Apply the decision method and make your recommendation.

Model answer. Immediate critical need; civilian alternative not comparable in time (48 h, or 6 h of dangerous road for seriously wounded people). Medical evacuation by military asset can be a last resort. Conditions: transport concerns only the wounded and strictly necessary medical staff, with no NGO logo or visible presence in the operation if possible; the decision is taken at the highest level in the country, documented, reported to OCHA; a message is prepared to explain to the armed group and communities that the evacuation follows medical criteria and that the NGO treats all wounded people, whatever their side. Review: do not make it a practice, seek an agreement for future civilian evacuations.

Required reading

Official, free documents. Answer the questions in writing: they prepare the deliverable and the exam.

  1. UN-CMCoord Field Handbook (version 2.0)
    OCHA · Open the document

    • Which dilemmas does the handbook present?
    • Which recommendations does it give for deciding?
    • Which lesson do you take for your plan?
  2. IASC Non-Binding Guidelines on the Use of Armed Escorts for Humanitarian Convoys (2013)
    Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) · Open the document

    • How do the guidelines organise decision-making at the highest level?
    • Which documentation do they require?
    • How can you draw on them for other dilemmas?
  3. OCHA e-learning modules (including civil-military coordination)
    OCHA, on DisasterReady · Open the document

    • Which additional module will you take after this programme?
    • How will you present your application to the UN-CMCoord course?
    • What is your training plan for the year?

Deliverable of the week : Complete CMCoord plan (final assignment)

Write an 8 to 10-page CMCoord plan for a real or realistic context, following the nine parts of the course: analysis and mapping, positions on the spectrum, operational rules, information and notification, access, protection, organisation, scenarios and warnings, indicators.

Marking grid (out of 20)

Justified analysis and positions4 pts
Clear operational rules4 pts
Information, access and protection5 pts
Organisation, scenarios and indicators5 pts
Quality of presentation2 pts
See the model answer (after writing your deliverable)

What a plan scoring 16/20 or more looks like.

Consistency. Each rule follows from the analysis; each scenario has its indicators and decisions.

Defensible. The plan could be presented as it is to a humanitarian country team: sources, figures, responsibilities, review.

Key points

  • Dilemmas often set lives saved today against tomorrow's access; texts give criteria, not all the answers.
  • Method: need, options, criteria, consultation, written decision at the right level, explanation, lessons.
  • Leadership: know, build trust on both sides, propose, hold the collective line, document.
  • The complete CMCoord plan covers analysis, positions, rules, information, access, protection, organisation, scenarios and monitoring.
  • For official training: OCHA's free modules, then the UN-CMCoord course.
A question about this module?

Ask the other participants: they are taking the same course as you.

Ask my question See this module's discussions

💼 Safety, security and access jobs

Put this course into practice: the latest jobs in this field.

See all 72 Safety, security and access jobs →

Prepare for the written test and interviewA model written test in this field, interview questions with sample answers and the STAR method.See the model test →
Further reading: course references
  1. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) (2018). UN-CMCoord Field Handbook (version 2.0). reliefweb.int/report/world/un-cmcoord-field-handbook-version-20-2018-enarfres
  2. OCHA (2007). Oslo Guidelines: Guidelines on the Use of Foreign Military and Civil Defence Assets in Disaster Relief (Rev. 1.1). digitallibrary.un.org/record/770364
  3. OCHA (2006). Guidelines on the Use of Military and Civil Defence Assets to Support United Nations Humanitarian Activities in Complex Emergencies (MCDA Guidelines, Rev. 1). reliefweb.int/report/world/guidelines-use-military-and-civil-defence-assets-support-united-nations-humanitarian
  4. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) (2004). Civil-Military Relationship in Complex Emergencies: an IASC Reference Paper. digitallibrary.un.org/record/697614
  5. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) (2013). IASC Non-Binding Guidelines on the Use of Armed Escorts for Humanitarian Convoys. webarchive.archive.unhcr.org/20151218190533if_/http://www.refworld.org/pdfid/523189ab4.pdf
  6. Centre of Competence on Humanitarian Negotiation (CCHN) (2019). Field Manual on Frontline Humanitarian Negotiation. frontline-negotiations.org
  7. ICRC and Brussels Privacy Hub (2020). Handbook on Data Protection in Humanitarian Action (2nd edition). www.icrc.org/en/data-protection-humanitarian-action-handbook
  8. United Nations Secretary-General (2003). Special measures for protection from sexual exploitation and sexual abuse (ST/SGB/2003/13). digitallibrary.un.org/record/504355/files/ST_SGB_2003_13-EN.pdf

Weekly quiz

5 demanding questions to check your learning. Answer them all to complete the week.

1In the decision method, what must always be included among the options?
2An effective CMCoord manager, faced with an unacceptable military request:
3Why document decisions and agreements?
4In the evacuation dilemma, the military helicopter can be a last resort because:
5The diploma of this Mini MBA:

← Week 11Final assessment →