Week 3 of 12 · 12 hours · Month 1

The normative framework: Oslo Guidelines, MCDA Guidelines, IASC reference paper

Objectives of the week
  • Identify the CMCoord reference texts, their scope and their value (non-binding but widely recognised).
  • Apply the common criteria: last resort, unique capability, civilian control, time limitation, distinction.
  • Explain the role of country-specific guidelines and how they are developed.

Keep the course at home: free PDF handout with exercises, key takeaways and quiz answers.

Download this lesson as PDF Complete manual (PDF)

Your working week : 12 h

The course alone is not enough: this plan spreads the 12 hours of the week. Tick each step once done.

1A set of texts, each for a context

CMCoord rests on guidelines negotiated between States, the United Nations and humanitarian organisations. They are not treaties, but they are widely recognised and form the basis of organisations' policies and national guidelines.

  • Oslo Guidelines (1994, revised in 2006 and updated in 2007): use of foreign military and civil defence assets in disasters, in peacetime.
  • MCDA Guidelines (2003, revised in 2006): use of military and civil defence assets to support United Nations humanitarian activities in complex emergencies.
  • IASC reference paper on civil-military relationships in complex emergencies (2004): principles and concepts for all humanitarian organisations.
  • IASC non-binding guidelines on armed escorts (2013): when and how an armed escort may, exceptionally, be accepted.
  • Country-specific guidelines: adaptation of the principles to a given context.

The UN-CMCoord field handbook (version 2.0, 2018) brings these texts together and explains how to apply them in practice.

2Last resort

The central criterion of all these texts is last resort: military assets are used to support humanitarian action only when there is no comparable civilian alternative and only their use can meet a critical humanitarian need.

"Comparable" is assessed in terms of capability and timeliness. If a civilian helicopter can arrive within 48 hours and that delay puts no lives at risk, the military asset is not a last resort. If no civilian asset can reach a cut-off area before people die, it may be.

Last resort is not measured by cost or convenience. A free and available military asset is not, for that reason alone, a last resort.

3The other common criteria

Beyond last resort, the texts converge on several rules:

  • Unique capability: the military asset provides what civilians cannot (heavy lift, engineering, airport, communications).
  • Civilian control: assets remain under military command, but the humanitarian operation remains under the overall authority of the responsible civilian organisation.
  • Limited in time and scale, with an exit strategy defined from the start.
  • Distinction: avoid humanitarian aid and personnel being confused with armed forces.
  • Request or consent of the affected State for any foreign deployment in a disaster.
  • Cost: the Oslo Guidelines provide that foreign military assistance should, in principle, be provided at no cost to the affected State.

4Disaster or conflict: why two texts

In a peacetime disaster, armed forces are not parties to a conflict: cooperation is easier and the Oslo Guidelines apply. In a complex emergency, association with an armed force can compromise perceived neutrality and endanger staff and beneficiaries: the MCDA Guidelines and the IASC reference paper require greater caution.

When a disaster strikes a conflict zone, the two logics meet. The practical rule: apply the criteria that best protect populations and staff, and analyse the military actor concerned case by case (affected State, foreign, party to the conflict or not).

5Country-specific guidelines

In many crises, the humanitarian country team (HCT) adopts country-specific guidelines, generally prepared by OCHA with humanitarian organisations. They set out:

  • the relationship mode with each armed actor present;
  • the rules on armed escorts, use of military assets and notification of movements;
  • the rules on information sharing;
  • the rules of conduct (visits to bases, transport in military vehicles, uniforms and weapons in premises).

They are adopted by the humanitarian leadership, shared with armed actors and revised when the context changes. Each organisation remains free in its decisions, but commits to respecting the common rules that protect the whole humanitarian community.

Exercise: is it a last resort?

A flood isolates 18,000 people. Three options exist to deliver 60 tonnes of food and water within 72 hours:

  1. Military helicopters of the national army, available immediately, free.
  2. Chartered civilian helicopters, available in 5 days, USD 180,000.
  3. Local civilian boats, available within 24 hours, total capacity of 20 tonnes per day.

The country is at peace. Which option do you recommend, and does the last-resort criterion apply?

Model answer. The boats deliver 20 tonnes per day from day 1: 60 tonnes in three days, within the 72-hour deadline. There is therefore a comparable civilian alternative for the requested volume; the military helicopters are not a last resort for this delivery, except for cases the boats cannot handle (urgent medical evacuations, areas unreachable by water). As the country is at peace, cooperation with the national army remains possible for these specific needs, under civilian control.

Required reading

Official, free documents. Answer the questions in writing: they prepare the deliverable and the exam.

  1. Oslo Guidelines: Guidelines on the Use of Foreign Military and Civil Defence Assets in Disaster Relief
    OCHA · Open the document

    • Which principles do the Oslo Guidelines set out?
    • How do they define last resort?
    • What do they say about the cost and control of assets?
  2. MCDA Guidelines: use of military and civil defence assets to support United Nations humanitarian activities in complex emergencies
    OCHA · Open the document

    • How do the MCDA Guidelines differ from the Oslo Guidelines?
    • Which precautions do they require in complex emergencies?
    • Which tasks do they consider most acceptable?
  3. Civil-Military Guidelines and Reference for Complex Emergencies (including the 2004 IASC reference paper)
    OCHA and IASC · Open the document

    • Which principles and concepts does the 2004 IASC reference paper set out?
    • How does it deal with distinction?
    • Which points still seem relevant to you?

Deliverable of the week : Comparative table of the texts and application to a case

Produce a table comparing the Oslo Guidelines, the MCDA Guidelines and the IASC reference paper (context, criteria, actors concerned), then apply them in 2 pages to a request for the use of military assets of your choice.

Marking grid (out of 20)

Accurate, complete table6 pts
Last resort correctly applied5 pts
Other criteria applied4 pts
Reasoned conclusion3 pts
Precise references2 pts
See the model answer (after writing your deliverable)

What work scoring 16/20 or more looks like.

Last resort. The civilian alternative is assessed in capacity and time, with figures; the fact that the military asset is free is not an argument.

Context. The work chooses the right text for the situation (disaster in peacetime, complex emergency) and applies the most protective criteria when in doubt.

Key points

  • Oslo: peacetime disasters, foreign assets. MCDA and IASC 2004: complex emergencies.
  • Last resort: no comparable civilian alternative in capability and timeliness, for a critical need.
  • Unique capability, civilian control, limited duration and planned exit, distinction, consent of the affected State.
  • Disaster in a conflict zone: apply the most protective criteria and analyse the actor case by case.
  • Country-specific guidelines turn these principles into common rules adopted by the humanitarian country team.
A question about this module?

Ask the other participants: they are taking the same course as you.

Ask my question See this module's discussions

💼 Safety, security and access jobs

Put this course into practice: the latest jobs in this field.

See all 72 Safety, security and access jobs →

Prepare for the written test and interviewA model written test in this field, interview questions with sample answers and the STAR method.See the model test →
Further reading: course references
  1. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) (2018). UN-CMCoord Field Handbook (version 2.0). reliefweb.int/report/world/un-cmcoord-field-handbook-version-20-2018-enarfres
  2. OCHA (2007). Oslo Guidelines: Guidelines on the Use of Foreign Military and Civil Defence Assets in Disaster Relief (Rev. 1.1). digitallibrary.un.org/record/770364
  3. OCHA (2006). Guidelines on the Use of Military and Civil Defence Assets to Support United Nations Humanitarian Activities in Complex Emergencies (MCDA Guidelines, Rev. 1). reliefweb.int/report/world/guidelines-use-military-and-civil-defence-assets-support-united-nations-humanitarian
  4. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) (2004). Civil-Military Relationship in Complex Emergencies: an IASC Reference Paper. digitallibrary.un.org/record/697614
  5. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) (2013). IASC Non-Binding Guidelines on the Use of Armed Escorts for Humanitarian Convoys. webarchive.archive.unhcr.org/20151218190533if_/http://www.refworld.org/pdfid/523189ab4.pdf
  6. Centre of Competence on Humanitarian Negotiation (CCHN) (2019). Field Manual on Frontline Humanitarian Negotiation. frontline-negotiations.org
  7. ICRC and Brussels Privacy Hub (2020). Handbook on Data Protection in Humanitarian Action (2nd edition). www.icrc.org/en/data-protection-humanitarian-action-handbook
  8. United Nations Secretary-General (2003). Special measures for protection from sexual exploitation and sexual abuse (ST/SGB/2003/13). digitallibrary.un.org/record/504355/files/ST_SGB_2003_13-EN.pdf

Weekly quiz

5 demanding questions to check your learning. Answer them all to complete the week.

1The Oslo Guidelines mainly concern:
2A free military asset is available, and a comparable civilian asset arrives in time. The military asset is:
3"Civilian control" means:
4Who generally adopts country-specific guidelines?
5The 2004 IASC reference paper deals with:

← Week 2Week 4 →