Week 1 of 12 · 12 hours · Month 1

Why coordinate with armed actors: principles and definition of CMCoord

Objectives of the week
  • Define humanitarian civil-military coordination (CMCoord) and distinguish it from military civil-military cooperation (CIMIC).
  • Explain how humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence guide every interaction with armed actors.
  • Place a relationship on the spectrum from cooperation to coexistence, and justify that choice according to the context.

Keep the course at home: free PDF handout with exercises, key takeaways and quiz answers.

Download this lesson as PDF Complete manual (PDF)

Your working week : 12 h

The course alone is not enough: this plan spreads the 12 hours of the week. Tick each step once done.

1Aid workers and weapons on the same ground

In almost every crisis, humanitarians share the space with armed actors: the armed forces of the affected State, foreign militaries that come to help after a disaster, peacekeepers, coalitions, non-State armed groups, police forces and private security companies. Ignoring them is impossible; being confused with them is dangerous.

After an earthquake, a military helicopter may be the only way to reach a cut-off valley. In a conflict, a convoy that moves without the belligerents knowing may be targeted. In both cases, the question is not "should we talk to the military?" but "how, about what and how far?".

Humanitarian civil-military coordination exists to protect two things at once: access to people in need and the humanitarian nature of aid.

2The reference definition

The United Nations field handbook on civil-military coordination (UN-CMCoord Field Handbook) defines CMCoord as the essential dialogue and interaction between civilian and military actors in humanitarian emergencies that is necessary to protect and promote humanitarian principles, avoid competition, minimise inconsistency and, when appropriate, pursue common goals.

The definition contains three ideas:

  • dialogue is essential, not optional;
  • it serves first to preserve the principles;
  • pursuing common goals is only possible "when appropriate", which depends on the context.

The handbook describes three basic tasks: information sharing, task division and planning. Their intensity varies with the context, from very close to almost none.

3CMCoord is not CIMIC

Armed forces have their own functions for relations with civilians: CIMIC (civil-military cooperation, in NATO and many armies), civil affairs or civil-military operations depending on the country. Their purpose is to support the military mission: facilitate movements, win the support of the population, reduce obstacles.

CMCoord, by contrast, is a humanitarian function, carried out by civilians, in the service of humanitarian objectives. The two talk to each other, but they have neither the same mandate nor the same criteria of success.

Example. A CIMIC unit offers to distribute school kits in a village where it also patrols. For the unit, it is a way to improve its image. For a humanitarian, it is a risk: people may associate all aid with that force, and schools may become potential targets.

4Humanitarian principles as a compass

Four principles, recognised by the United Nations General Assembly (resolutions 46/182 of 1991 and 58/114 of 2003) and by the Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, guide every decision:

  • Humanity: relieve suffering wherever it is found, protect life and dignity.
  • Neutrality: take no side in hostilities or in political, religious or ideological controversies.
  • Impartiality: help on the basis of need alone, giving priority to the most urgent cases, without discrimination.
  • Independence: keep humanitarian objectives autonomous from political, economic or military objectives.

An interaction with an armed actor is judged by its effect on these principles, both real and perceived. A sound decision that people misunderstand can cost access.

5The spectrum: from cooperation to coexistence

The relationship between humanitarians and the military sits on a spectrum:

  • Cooperation: in peacetime or after a natural disaster, when the affected State's army or foreign forces help under civilian control. Information sharing, task division and joint planning can be close.
  • Coordination: intermediate situations, for example a peacekeeping mission that is not a party to the conflict.
  • Coexistence: in armed conflict, especially when the force present is a party to hostilities. Contact is limited to what is needed to avoid competition, reduce risks and protect civilians.

The choice is not fixed once and for all: a disaster in a conflict zone, or a peace mission turning into a fighting force, moves the relationship along the spectrum.

6What this programme is, and what it is not

This Mini MBA is an independent course of the Humanitarian Academy of Humanitaires Jobs. It is based on the public reference texts: the Oslo Guidelines, the MCDA Guidelines, the IASC reference paper on civil-military relationships in complex emergencies, the IASC non-binding guidelines on armed escorts and the UN-CMCoord field handbook.

It does not replace OCHA's official UN-CMCoord course and does not award any United Nations certification. For the official training, take OCHA's free online modules, then apply for the UN-CMCoord course. The links are in this week's readings.

Exercise: where does the relationship sit?

For each of the following situations, give the position on the spectrum (cooperation, coordination, coexistence) and one action to avoid.

  1. A cyclone hits a country at peace. The national army clears roads and offers its trucks.
  2. A foreign force is fighting an armed group in the north of a country. It offers to carry food to the villages it has just retaken.
  3. A peacekeeping mission, not a party to the conflict, patrols around a displacement camp.

Model answer. 1: cooperation, under civilian control; avoid letting the army choose the beneficiaries alone. 2: coexistence; avoid using its trucks, which would associate aid with a party to the conflict. 3: coordination; avoid handing distribution or registration of displaced people to the mission.

Required reading

Official, free documents. Answer the questions in writing: they prepare the deliverable and the exam.

  1. UN-CMCoord Field Handbook (version 2.0)
    OCHA · Open the document

    • How does the handbook define humanitarian civil-military coordination?
    • What are the three basic tasks, and how do they vary with the context?
    • What difference does the handbook make between CMCoord and CIMIC?
  2. OCHA e-learning modules (including civil-military coordination)
    OCHA, on DisasterReady · Open the document

    • Which OCHA modules deal with civil-military coordination?
    • How long does it take to complete them?
    • Which one will you take first, and why?
  3. Fundamental principles and international humanitarian law
    International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) · Open the document

    • Which texts form the core of international humanitarian law?
    • Which rules protect civilians and humanitarian staff?
    • Which principle seems hardest to preserve in your context?

Deliverable of the week : Position note: where the civil-military relationship stands in your context

Choose a real or realistic context and write a 3-page note.

  1. Context: type of crisis, armed actors present.
  2. Position on the spectrum for each armed actor, justified.
  3. Principles at stake: which are most threatened, and why.
  4. Three rules of conduct you recommend to your organisation.

Marking grid (out of 20)

Precise, sourced context4 pts
Justified positions on the spectrum5 pts
Analysis of real and perceived principles5 pts
Concrete, applicable rules4 pts
Clarity and concision2 pts
See the model answer (after writing your deliverable)

What a note scoring 16/20 or more looks like.

Positions. The note distinguishes between actors: cooperation is possible with national civil protection after a flood, coexistence with a force that is a party to the conflict, coordination with a peace mission that is not a party.

Principles. It analyses perception: for example, neutrality is threatened if communities see humanitarian vehicles inside bases.

Mistakes that cost points. Treating "the military" as one bloc; confusing CIMIC and CMCoord; vague rules ("avoid where possible").

Key points

  • CMCoord is the essential dialogue between civilians and the military to protect principles and access, not systematic cooperation.
  • Three basic tasks: information sharing, task division, planning.
  • CIMIC serves the military mission; CMCoord serves humanitarian objectives.
  • Humanity, neutrality, impartiality, independence: every interaction is judged by its real and perceived effect.
  • Spectrum: cooperation in natural disasters, coexistence in armed conflict, with intermediate situations.
A question about this module?

Ask the other participants: they are taking the same course as you.

Ask my question See this module's discussions

💼 Safety, security and access jobs

Put this course into practice: the latest jobs in this field.

See all 72 Safety, security and access jobs →

Prepare for the written test and interviewA model written test in this field, interview questions with sample answers and the STAR method.See the model test →
Further reading: course references
  1. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) (2018). UN-CMCoord Field Handbook (version 2.0). reliefweb.int/report/world/un-cmcoord-field-handbook-version-20-2018-enarfres
  2. OCHA (2007). Oslo Guidelines: Guidelines on the Use of Foreign Military and Civil Defence Assets in Disaster Relief (Rev. 1.1). digitallibrary.un.org/record/770364
  3. OCHA (2006). Guidelines on the Use of Military and Civil Defence Assets to Support United Nations Humanitarian Activities in Complex Emergencies (MCDA Guidelines, Rev. 1). reliefweb.int/report/world/guidelines-use-military-and-civil-defence-assets-support-united-nations-humanitarian
  4. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) (2004). Civil-Military Relationship in Complex Emergencies: an IASC Reference Paper. digitallibrary.un.org/record/697614
  5. Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC) (2013). IASC Non-Binding Guidelines on the Use of Armed Escorts for Humanitarian Convoys. webarchive.archive.unhcr.org/20151218190533if_/http://www.refworld.org/pdfid/523189ab4.pdf
  6. Centre of Competence on Humanitarian Negotiation (CCHN) (2019). Field Manual on Frontline Humanitarian Negotiation. frontline-negotiations.org
  7. ICRC and Brussels Privacy Hub (2020). Handbook on Data Protection in Humanitarian Action (2nd edition). www.icrc.org/en/data-protection-humanitarian-action-handbook
  8. United Nations Secretary-General (2003). Special measures for protection from sexual exploitation and sexual abuse (ST/SGB/2003/13). digitallibrary.un.org/record/504355/files/ST_SGB_2003_13-EN.pdf

Weekly quiz

5 demanding questions to check your learning. Answer them all to complete the week.

1According to the field handbook, the three basic CMCoord tasks are:
2An army's CIMIC function serves first of all:
3In an armed conflict where the force present is fighting, the relationship is most often:
4The principle that forbids taking sides in hostilities is:
5This Mini MBA:

← OverviewWeek 2 →