- Carry out the needs, stakeholder and problem analysis that justifies a project.
- Move from the problem tree to the objective tree, then choose a strategy through analysis of alternatives.
- Explain what a project proposal must contain to pass the decision gate.
Keep the course at home: free PDF handout with exercises, key takeaways and quiz answers.
Your working day : 6 h
The course alone is not enough: this plan spreads the 6 hours of the day. Tick each step once done.
1Why this phase is decisive
A well-executed but badly designed project is still a failure: it solves the wrong problem, in the wrong place, for the wrong people. The identification and definition phase answers four questions: what is the real need? who is concerned? what are its causes? which strategy is most likely to succeed?
It ends with a decision: whether or not to invest in a project, based on a reasoned proposal. In our sector, this proposal often takes the form of a concept note and then a full proposal to the donor.
2Collect data and analyse needs
Data combine secondary sources (existing reports, cluster assessments, national statistics) and primary sources (interviews, focus groups, surveys, observation). The right reflex: start with secondary data so as not to exhaust communities with repeated surveys.
The analysis distinguishes needs (the gap between the current situation and a desirable one), existing capacities and specific vulnerabilities (women, children, people with disabilities, minorities). Data should be disaggregated by sex, age and disability whenever possible.
3Stakeholder analysis
A stakeholder is any person or organisation that influences the project or is affected by it. They are identified, then their interest, influence, expectations and attitude (supportive, neutral, opposed) are analysed.
The influence / interest matrix guides engagement: manage closely (high influence and interest), keep satisfied (high influence, low interest), keep informed (high interest, low influence), monitor (both low). Affected communities often have little formal power but maximum interest: participation and accountability require that they be genuinely involved.
4Problem tree and objective tree
The problem tree places the core problem at the trunk, its causes at the roots and its effects in the branches. Example: core problem "high prevalence of diarrhoeal disease among children under 5"; causes: unsafe water, lack of latrines, hygiene practices; effects: malnutrition, school absenteeism, health expenses.
The objective tree turns each negative situation into a desired positive one: causes become means, the core problem becomes the objective, effects become ends. "Cause → effect" links become "means → end" links.
Exam trap: the objective tree does not yet say what the project will do. The analysis of alternatives chooses the branches to keep.
5Analysis of alternatives and choice of strategy
Several possible strategies are compared (for example: boreholes, spring rehabilitation, household water treatment) using explicit criteria: needs covered, cost, technical feasibility, sustainability, risks, the organisation's capacities, donor priorities, presence of other actors, communities' views.
A weighted scoring matrix makes the choice transparent. The strategy chosen defines the project's scope: what will be done and, just as important, what will not.
6The proposal and the decision gate
The proposal brings together: justification and context analysis, theory of change and logical framework, target groups, main activities, estimated budget, risks and assumptions, monitoring and evaluation approach, sustainability. It must be consistent: every activity contributes to a result, every cost matches an activity.
The end-of-phase decision gate asks: is the need demonstrated? is the strategy the best option? does the organisation have the capacity? is funding likely? If the answer is no, the proposal is improved or the project is dropped.
Exercise: from problem tree to objective tree
Situation. In Koro, an assessment shows that 38% of children under 5 had diarrhoea last month. Causes found: only 4 functioning water points for 9,000 inhabitants; 22% of households have a latrine; handwashing with soap is rare. Effects: malnutrition, health costs, school absenteeism.
Task. 1) Write the problem tree. 2) Turn it into an objective tree. 3) Suggest three criteria to choose between a "water" strategy and a "sanitation and hygiene" strategy.
Answer. 1) Trunk: high prevalence of diarrhoea among under-5s; roots: insufficient access to safe water, low latrine coverage, risky hygiene practices; branches: malnutrition, health expenses, absenteeism. 2) Trunk: prevalence reduced; roots: increased access to safe water, increased latrine coverage, improved hygiene practices; branches: better nutritional status, lower expenses, better attendance. 3) Examples: cost per person covered, sustainability (who maintains?), presence of other actors on the same cause.
Guided reading
Official, free documents. Answer the questions in writing: in an open-book exam, knowing where to look wins.
Project DPro Guide, "Project identification and definition" phase
PM4NGOs, 2nd edition (free) · Open the document- Which steps does the guide describe in this phase, and in what order?
- Which analysis tools are proposed for stakeholders and problems?
- What must the proposal contain to pass the decision gate?
Core Humanitarian Standard, commitment 4 (participation of affected people)
CHS Alliance (free) · Open the document- What does the standard require on the participation of affected people in decisions that concern them?
- How can it be applied during project identification, even before funding is secured?
Deliverable of the day : Problem analysis and choice of strategy for your common-thread project
For your common-thread project, write two pages: 1) a problem tree (at least 3 causes and 3 effects); 2) the matching objective tree; 3) a stakeholder matrix (at least 6 actors, classified by influence and interest); 4) two strategies compared with at least 4 weighted criteria, and the strategy chosen.
Marking grid (out of 20)
| Logical problem tree (causes and effects correctly placed) | 5 pts |
| Objective tree faithful to the problem tree | 4 pts |
| Complete stakeholders, communities included, suitable engagement | 5 pts |
| Transparent and justified choice of strategy | 6 pts |
See the model answer points (after writing your deliverable)
Expected points. Each cause really is a cause of the core problem (test: "because…"); each effect follows from it (test: "therefore…"). Communities and local authorities appear in the matrix. The choice matrix shows weights, scores and total; the strategy chosen has the best score, or any difference is explained.
Key points
- Start with secondary sources, then add primary data disaggregated by sex, age and disability.
- Influence / interest matrix: manage closely, keep satisfied, keep informed, monitor.
- Problem tree: causes below, problem in the middle, effects above; the objective tree is its positive image.
- The analysis of alternatives, with explicit criteria, sets the strategy and therefore the scope.
- The phase ends with a decision gate on the proposal.
Ask the other participants: they are taking the same course as you.
💼 Programme management jobs
Put this course into practice: the latest jobs in this field.
- Asistente de investigación sobre asuntos macroeconómicos, fiscales y de precios de la ArgentinaEconomic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean · Argentina
- Facilitator for FPFSACDO · Afghanistan
- Consultant International CAPI, Coordonnateur des IT, en appui au processus du deuxième Recensement Général de la Population et de l’Habitat (RGPH2) de la RDCUNFPA · DR Congo
- Менеджер/ка з комунікацій / івент-менеджер/ка в ТатоХабГО ХОЦ Успішна жінка · Ukraine
- Regional Strategy & Business Development Advisor, WCA2Clinton Health Access Initiative (CHAI) · Burkina Faso
Further reading: course references
- PM4NGOs (2020). Project DPro Guide (PMD Pro, 2nd edition): project management for development professionals. pm4ngos.org/methodologies-guides/project-dpro
- PM4NGOs (2026). Exams & Certificates: format, rules and fees of the Project DPro exam. pm4ngos.org/candidates-and-learners/exams-certificates
- PM4NGOs (2024). Practice / Sample Exam: free Project DPro Foundation practice exam. pm4ngos.org/candidates-and-learners/practice-sample-exam/project-dpro-pmd-pro-foundation
- PM4NGOs (2019). MEAL DPro: monitoring, evaluation, accountability and learning guide. pm4ngos.org/methodologies-guides/meal-dpro
- CHS Alliance, Groupe URD, Sphere (2024). Core Humanitarian Standard on Quality and Accountability (CHS). www.corehumanitarianstandard.org
Daily quiz
8 questions to check what you have learned. Answer them all to complete the day.